Writing in Prospect magazine in October last year Peter Jukes maintained that US tv drama has become superior to British tv drama as a result of structural problems in the BBC. Lauding US police drama, The Wire in particular, he said, 'US television dramas have evolved into an art form which explores both the inner psyche and the social psyche continuously but discretely, so that each fragment contains the fractal beauty of the whole.' You can read the whole article here www.prospectmagazine.co.uk/2009/10/why-b
Well I've just started watching series one of The Wire and I'm only three episodes in so maybe it's too early for a judgement but for a show that is praised by all on account of its gritty realism, there have been some highly improbable moments so far. Like the scene in episode two in which a young gang member, hauled in by police, is persuaded in the absence of a lawyer, to write a letter of apology to the children of a man murdered by his associates. In real life an individual in this young man's position, streetwise and smart, would simply never have fallen for such a stunt.
I've also just fnished watching the second series of Wallander made by the BBC, starring Kenneth Brannagh. It has its share of plot implausibilities as well but the performance by Branagh is so utterly compelling that you simply do not care. It has been fashionable to look down on Branagh in some quarters, particularly after the failure of Frankenstein. But in this drama he has been nothing short of stunning.
I was born in England but my ethnicity is Irish and that's how I see myself - still an outsider here in many ways. Perhaps that's why I do not share the trait so often displayed in the British character, particularly on the left for some reason, of knocking notable British achievements. In my opinion the BBC still produces drama of the very highest quality whatever carpers like Peter Jukes might say.
